On Expertise: Part 2

Ya’ ready for a story with absolutely no specific details? Has the political season inured you to that yet? Great, here goes:

Consider society as a whole. We live in a sophisticated interlocking network of skills and technologies the likes of which has never before existed. The average person may have an iPhone but virtually none of us have the slightest fucking clue how it operates. Or why. Or how to fix it if it breaks.

We all sense that someone somewhere does know. Some smart motherfucker in a labcoat somewhere can make the chips that drive it. Some other smart person knows the chemistry of the batteries we bitch about. A group of smart people setup the communication network for which the phone itself is merely an access point. A smart but devious group create the code-based wiring harness that lets Facebook jack straight into your cortex. Etc…

From there it goes downhill. An army of not quite as clever but still very competent people keep the towers standing and the system powered. Others code stupid games and make sure you can track your pizza delivery. The lowest group picks the box color and try to convince us to embrace immense monthly payment plans. A final loud and annoying group of drooling morons scheme to call it a “human right” so politicians will subsidize free phones for the livestock on the vote farm.

The point is… I always imagine a smart fraction that really does know how this shit is done. It’s important they’re still with us. It matters to me. I want them to exist. I need them to exist.

Unfortunately, they might not. I keep looking behind the curtain. I do some odd thing that most people think is “impossible” and start realizing the good and bad of it. The good: nothing is impossible. The bad: if there’s a magic tiny fraction of geniuses… they’re not taking my calls. Are they merged in with the rest of humanity? Maybe they’re skilled in only one thing? Fuckin’ wizards at making cell phone chips, but otherwise just as clueless as anyone else? A one dimensional 185 IQ savant/dweeb that fights against Moore’s Law like a boss but can’t drive a stick shift car. A powerhouse of technology who just bought an extended warranty for their toaster.

Maybe the wise ones don’t exist! Holy shit!

The mind boggles! I feel the firmament give way. Count to ten. Breathe… OK I’m all calmed down now. I can continue…

Let’s start with the good. You can have the same experience as me. Just do something that’s “impossible”. It’s not really that hard. The world is awash with people who carry lists in their head of what cannot be done. The list is long, comprehensive, and pathetic. It serves as blinders to keep the scary outside world from intruding on their pedestrian thoughts. By their logic, if something demonstrably has been done (someone built the iPad… it wasn’t grown) but it’s not dirt simple; then the easiest way to avoid responsibility for thinking about it is to assume it can only be done by super-secret magicians from far away. That’s the root of the list of things that mere mortals can’t do.

Society keeps trying to add to the list. They’ve nearly convinced millennials that wearing pants and showing up to work is beyond their abilities. What’s next? Toilet training?

Regardless, pick something from that list. Pick something that’s hard. Then do it.

It feels good to do things. It also pokes holes in that “super-secret magicians” idea. An example; years ago I was making biodiesel. The chemistry isn’t that hard so I just did it. I bought a book and figured it out. I was careful. I learned. In time I was making an excellent product. In case you’re wondering, my truck ran just fine.

Instead of impressed, acquaintances reacted with suspicion and worry. I had offended the Gods! It was as if Exxon had a direct line to the universe where they downloaded pure energy… and that’s how your vehicle is powered. A “deplorable” like me churning out the same thing with French fry grease and a machine made of plumbing fittings broke the spell. They didn’t like it. They resented it.

But that never stopped me from believing that the smart people are out there. If I only had the right contacts. If I only knew the right people. I’d make a call, offer up a bottle of scotch, and listen carefully. I’d learn. I’d gain valuable knowledge. I’d avoid re-inventing the wheel. I wouldn’t have to muddle through. I just needed to make contact with those smart fellas.

Nope.

Recently I was trying to build a thing. What “thing” is beyond the point. The point is that many have gone before me. Humanity knows how to do this particular thing. They know the pros and cons of this widget versus that snerkdoodle. They know how many foot pounds to torque the frabnabulator.

But there’s nobody to communicate it to me. Like the matrix, I’ll just have to see it for myself. No shortcuts allowed. Humbly beseeching the wisdom of the greats does nothing if the greats ‘aint organized enough to talk it out. I could find a thousand references on the internet to one or another detail of my “thing of interest”. But no cohesive whole. No unified theory. Just a lot of fools like me… most of them with bigger budgets. Some buying this part, some buying that. Some making careful measurements of the results, others hoping it was good enough.

Q: “Did you stress test the load bearing whammerflacks?”

A: “It’s still standing.”

It’s an answer but it isn’t. If you want to design for a 5287 Newton-Gauss of whammerflack load it’s damn near useless. It’s just another story about whammerflacks. It hints at the universal whammerflack strength coefficient but tells you they don’t know the coefficient either.

Another cherished notion fades. I already knew the only way the idiots on Gilligan’s Island were going to get home was if they listened to the Professor. Now I know the Professor wasn’t 100% sure how the coconut radio worked. He made it, it filled the plot device, but anyone else who wants their own radio is going to have to get there on their own. The Professor ‘aint going to give a TED talk about the coconut radio that explains it all… because he’s not truly certain himself.

Fuck! We’re never getting off this island!

I gave up on finding a grizzled expert to help guide my project. I’d called several people with experience in the matter. All came up with some sort of excuse. “I’m pretty snofty on the jimmerjams but you’re asking about whammerflaks and I haven’t used them before.” They mostly offered helpful but not helpful breadcrumbs about their own path. “If you desire to go for jimmerjams, try installing the Excelsior X0293 with the optional tailfins. I love mine.”

I gave up. I’ll “wing it”. I ordered some random shit from the internet. It’ll work. Or it won’t. Most likely there will be mixed results. It’ll be a disaster when north-north-west: when the wind is southerly I’ll know a hawk from a handsaw and the fucker will run beautifully.

I wonder if my toddler thought the same thing when he asked me about whatever thing he was going to do. Was that his first step in the path I’m following right now? “Fuck him, he’s got no clue. I’ll just stick this thing in my mouth and see if it’s food.” How is that different from me right now? “Fuck it, I’ll order a part on Amazon and hope the thread pitch matches.”

As I age, I grudgingly accept we are all toddlers.

About AdaptiveCurmudgeon

Adaptive Curmudgeon is handsome, brave, and wise.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to On Expertise: Part 2

  1. Educated Savage says:

    You and Jordan Peterson in a room together would be interesting…

    • Cloudbuster says:

      Maybe they’re skilled in only one thing? Fuckin’ wizards at making cell phone chips, but otherwise just as clueless as anyone else? A one dimensional 185 IQ savant/dweeb that fights against Moore’s Law like a boss but can’t drive a stick shift car. A powerhouse of technology who just bought an extended warranty for their toaster.

      It is this. I don’t know if that is a comfort of a worry, but I know these guys, and that is how it works, for the most part.

  2. Weisshaupt says:

    The Magicians are out there.. but they are competent at only one, very narrow, form of magic. In all other areas of life they are as incompetent and clueless as everyone else. The internet is great for building a wang-pow-whatzit if the magicians who do that are also interested in the internet. Your Wormastrader is obviously not of that class ( I am guessing it is farm equipment- farmers and ranchers do not use the internet) – they use this thing called word of mouth.. and as the old farmers die off that system is breaking down.. but somewhere there is a club of guys with a big shop full of old Wormastraders in pieces and a few working machines. This workshop exists – and probably will till the last magician who still does that crap dies.. but finding it will become progressively more difficult… but start asking around at local stores that sell the parts.. and the stores that don’t– because often they know the stores that do. An those guys will know who buys those odd parts “you are working on a Wormastrader?!? Don’t see much of that anymore. Do you know Bill? I has like 50 of them in pieces…” “No, I don’t know Bill, but I need to. Anyway I could get a hold of him?” Sounds likea mythical quest story ? It is – but you are the one who put yourself on it. — And maybe at some point – I might hit you up on building a diesel plant 🙂

  3. Jon says:

    We’re we so lucky to be toddlers. Boundless energy, supreme curiosity, willingness to try new things, intense desire to learn and dominate their environment, and the protection of giants who genuinely have toddlers best interest at heart.

    So many “adults” are happy to accept the opinions and limitations imposed by their betters. There is still a remnant willing to take their own path, learning through hard experience, and accepting the consequences of choices good and bad. It’s the remnant that expands frontiers and makes life pleasant and safe for the many.

    Keep that motorcycle running and kitted up with great accessory “modifications”. We all need a vehicle to connect with nature and undisturbed creation.

  4. p2 says:

    I need to find one o’ them guys. I’ve got a plane with problem that only shows up in the air. I’ve changed the jimmerjam, swapped the whammerflack from left engine to right to see if the problem follows and retorqued the connections on the snerkdoodle. The flootney valve is working, the angry pixie paths are sound and the kanooter linkage is tight. Anyway I can get ahold of Bill?

    As usual, great start to yet another great read. Keep ’em comin’….

  5. Anonymous says:

    Mate, I think *you* are one of those smart ones you seek.

  6. Terrapod says:

    In a close parallel, I take on any project that comes along with the correct attitude, and that is “if a Mexican/Indian/Chinaman can assemble it, I can do the reverse and fix it. My basement and shop are strewn with :”whammerflacks” in partial stage of repair, waiting for a part or for motivation to complete the job. It is the latter that seems to escape me more now than before, that and needing bloody magnifying goggles to see the parts. Thank God for magnetic tip screwdrivers as the fasteners are no longer of a size to be picked up by human hands..

  7. John Wilder says:

    I remember (very long ago) that I was watching my daughter and another little girl – I had exactly four years of experience as a parent. The “not mine” little girl pulled the cushions off of the couch and proceeded to jump from one to the next.

    “Stop it,” I said in my best adult voice.

    “Why?” asked “not mine”.

    I stopped. There was no real reason. They weren’t hurting anything, and couldn’t hurt themselves.

    Me: “Nevermind. Keep going.”

    Yup. I was winging it.

  8. MadRocketSci says:

    I’ve always (even before encountering it) took Heinlein’s “specialization is for insects” speech to heart. I want to know how everything works. It’s impossible, but I need to try anyway.

    Not knowing what is going on with any given device or process has always been embarrassing. What if I needed to rebuild industrial civilization starting with duct tape and a coconut? (When I was a kid, it was actually panic inducing: I didn’t *want* to know how things worked, I *NEEDED* to know how things worked. Kids don’t know anything. I wasn’t a very calm kid.)

    BTW: Now I have a workshop, so that’s in the plus column. I’m buying shop equipment as I can. In the minus column, migraines are eating my brain and I can’t focus anywhere near as well as I used to.

  9. Tree Mike says:

    I found out from some one smarter than me (lots of ’em out there) when looking for How To for an 86 Toyota rear break diy. Only one How To by a female with a Toyota close enough. Turns out (((They))) are financializing everything behind pay walls. Keep the serfs ignorant, dependent and taxed into poverty. Ymmv.

    • Terrapod says:

      Tree Mike – find out what the european name is for the model car you want to work on and then do a YouTube search for that. I find how to stuff online that originates in EU or former Soviet Block and is free for any to look at. The English may be tough to follow or it can be German or some Turk doing repairs on his sidewalk, but the “know how” is there visually if the guy is not hopped up on too much caffeine..Be aware that some of the things they do are dangerous as heck, so user beware.

  10. MadRocketSci says:

    “Fuck him, he’s got no clue. I’ll just stick this thing in my mouth and see if it’s food.” How is that different from me right now? “Fuck it, I’ll order a part on Amazon and hope the thread pitch matches.”

    My Labmate: Dude! Where did you find that hardware? I was looking all over for something that would work. What is it?
    Me: 1/4″-20
    My Labmate: I tried that. Whatever it is it isn’t 1/4″-20.
    Me holding up a tap: Whatever it was, it is now.

  11. Carl G. says:

    I know it’s a very slim chance, but you might mention what your trying to build here on the blog. Maybe there is a wizard of that field, or somebody who knows one, reading this. You’re never gonna know that however if you demand everybody sign an NDA about the project before you tell them ‘good morning.’

    Just sayin’. Reach out a little. Sometimes it’s a pleasant surprise who you bump into on the internet.

    • AdaptiveCurmudgeon says:

      For this topic I’ll refrain for privacy reasons.

      You’ve got a good point and sometimes I have indeed gotten a good hint from comments. I’ll remember to try fishing for knowledge here in my own little pond the next time I need some brain power.

Leave a Reply